Poll: Should ObamaCare be ruled unconstitutional?

The fate of the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (aka ObamaCare) seems to be decided by how 2 key conservative justices—John Roberts and Anthony Kennedy—determine the constitutionality of the mandate requiring everyone to buy health insurance. The panel of 9 justices appear to be divided along the ideological line, with 5 justices (appointed by the last 3 Republican presidents) questioned the constitutionality of the mandate while the 4 justices (appointed by Clinton and Obama) defended the law.

The last day of Supreme Court hearing of the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (aka Obamacare) was mainly about whether the whole law could stand on his own if the mandate requiring everyone to have coverage was to be ruled unconstitutional.

Some arguments or comments:

  • The states challenged that the whole ObamaCare should be removed if the mandate is ruled unconstitutional—if you do not have the individual mandate to force people into the market then community rating and guaranteed-issue will cause the cost of premiums to skyrocket.
  • Justice Antonin Scalia also agreed, “When we strike that down, it’s clear that Congress would not have passed it without that
  • Justice Kagan wondered, “Is half a loaf better than no loaf?
  • Justice Kennedy worried about the unintended consequences in the form of increased cost if the mandate is removed—“We would be exercising the judicial power if one Act was — one provision was stricken and the others remained to impose a risk on insurance companies that Congress had never intended. By reason of this Court, we would have a new regime that Congress did not provide for, did not consider.
  • Justice Ginsburg argued that other parts of the law have not been challenged in court, why should Congress redo those.

What do you believe?

If the mandate requiring everyone to have insurance coverage is ruled unconstitutional, should the whole ObamaCare be invalidated as well—knowing that without this mandate the premiums will increase hugely?

Ch3 Nguyen

Advertisements

2 comments on “Poll: Should ObamaCare be ruled unconstitutional?

  1. ok- so you do realize- The individual mandate was a republican idea, first developed in the late 80’s, improved by the Heritage Foundation, introduced and widely supported by republicans in 1993, incorporated in Romneycare with glowing praise from Republicans and the Heritage Foundation, and supported and pushed by many republicans at the beginning of the Obamacare debate
    See my blogs here: http://goo.gl/2eRi7 and here: http://goo.gl/jVWgI

    And of course Paul Ryan and the Republicans “new and improved” plan is even me egregious- see my blog here: http://goo.gl/cYoFj

    And oh yes- as much as the right has been claiming that a majority of americans are opposed to Obamacare, the polls that have dug a little deeper found that in fact around 10% of those “opposed” are not actually against obamacare per se- but feel that it doesn’t go far enough (ie: no public option), which changes the truth of what these numbers are saying. See my blog here: http://goo.gl/F3jL6

  2. In 2009, ObamaCare was passed mainly by both Houses that were controlled by Democrats–with some “blue” dogs were forced to go along. I believe no Republican voted for it.
    RomneyCare is at the state level. State can require people to buy insurance–i.e. they can force people buying car insurance, for example.
    And speaking of current polls…
    http://realclearpolitics.com/epolls/other/repeal_of_health_care_law_favoroppose-1947.html
    A Rasmussen poll (3/17 – 3/18) showed 56% favor repeal while 39% oppose repeal.
    And a Gallup poll (2/19 – 2/20) showed 47% favor repeal while 44% oppose repeal.
    A Quinnipac poll (2/14 – 2/20) showed 52% favor repeal while 39% oppose repeal.
    Quite consistent, aren’t they?

    BTW, did you vote in this blog’s poll?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s